Inspirations
from the Jewish Experience: Haman and Hitler
In some circles, Purim has the reputation
of being a rather foolish holiday that is devoid of God or faith,
a Jewish child's answer to Halloween. Yet Purim also has a communal
mitzvah--the reading of Megillat Esther, the Book of Esther. During
the Holocaust, Yaakov Frankel testifies to performing this mitzvah
from a Megillat Esther written from memory on scraps of paper by a
group of men in Buchenwald, who accompanied their reading by spontaneous
dancing and singing (Those Who Did Not Surrender, 1963).
 |
There
are countless ways to reflect and learn from the traditions
and central themes present in Purim that can deepen our insight
into the Holocaust era. We learn from the differences, from
the obvious--in the Purim story the genocide was successfully
prevented--and from the less obvious but no less meaningful--that
the Jews were given permission and support to fight their enemies
in a country not their own. But it is the similarities that
are most compelling. |
Jewish children's
most profound memory of the Megillah reading is the 'wiping out'
of the name of Haman, the descendent of Amalek, by creating loud
noise with their graggers. In this way, children are taught to recognize
evil but not to fear it. In a loud and rowdy attempt to blot out
Haman's name, children understand the powerful message that the
Jewish people survive. From countless testimonies recorded from
the ghettos and camps, we learn that at the time of Purim, Hitler's
name was often substituted for Haman's name. Both in jest and with
intense seriousness, privately or even openly in front of guards
and officials, the names of Haman and the Amalekites were invoked
by Jews of all backgrounds when referring to Hitler and his henchmen:
Himmler, Heydrich, Hess, Eichman, Goebbels, Goering and others.
Today, it is often an unquestioned practice in Holocaust education
and museums to give prominence to Nazi personalities and their actions.
Jewish sites and curricula could learn from the Purim story to de-emphasize
the Nazi leaders, their political dogma and paraphernalia. This
would invite possibilities to know and honor the names of the Mordechais
and Esthers who were present throughout the Holocaust years. Jews
and non-Jews sought to warn and fight against the destruction of
the Jewish people. By giving so much attention to Haman/Hitler and
his followers, we often neglect many extraordinary heroes. The reader
can accept the challenge of comparing how many names might be remembered
from the Nazi hierarchy with the names of the Righteous Among the
Nations and Holocaust victims. This applied Purim lesson redirects
us to prevent evil and identify role models while simultaneously
drowning out the names of the perpetrators.
Yet we must remember that Purim is primarily a day of laughter and
fun, commemorating when catastrophe was averted. "Purim"
means lottery, a game of chance that Haman arbitrarily used to choose
the exact day to slaughter the Jews in every Persian province, from
India to Ethiopia.
We also must remember that even in the camps there was humor. The
following joke circulated among Jewish inmates in many camps:
Hitler asked an astrologist if he would lose the war and perish.
Yes, he was told.
When, he asked.
On a Jewish holiday.
Which one?
Any day you die will be a Jewish holiday.
For ten years, Steve Lipman interviewed survivors to collect jokes,
anecdotes, and puns from the time of the Holocaust for his book
Laughter in Hell: Use of Humor During the Holocaust. He describes
laughter as not only a distraction to help overcome fear, but as
a life-affirming way to reinforce humanity and a sense of self.
In honor of Purim, we share two stories of Lipman's Holocaust humor:
From Germany: Mr. Goldberg had a meeting at the U.S. Embassy in
Berlin in 1938. The clerk denied him a visa, and excused his actions
by pointing to a globe in the corner of the room and saying "You
can't find a place on this globe that will give a visa to Jews."
Mr. Goldberg replied, hopefully: "Don't you have another globe?"
From the Warsaw Ghetto: Haim was reading a tattered newspaper while
waiting for a clandestine minyan to gather. Moshe walks in and peers
over his shoulder. Shocked, he asks Haim: "Why are you reading
this SS garbage, Der Sturmer? And on Shabbos!" Haim replied,
"Look, it says here that the Jews have all the money! Jews
run the world! Roosevelt is a Jew! Moshe, can't I dream a little?"
In Auschwitz, Viktor Frankl and another medical colleague explored
ways to survive. They decided to tell a funny story every day about
what will happen after liberation (Man's Search for Meaning, 1959).
Many others joined them to create this compilation. Not only did
this activity empower, it also created solidarity and reinforced
hope.
Humor has kept the Jewish people resilient. By celebrating Purim
with mirth and merriment, though it commemorates the first edict
of genocide, we signal an annual occurrence when Jews find that
the power of laughter is stronger than tears.
The Talmud says, in the name of Elijah, that there will be rewards
in the world-to-come for those who brought laughter into this one
(Ta'anit 22a).
|